A site about-whatever.
Anyone have an opinion on the relationship between classical and "modern" music?
Published on March 2, 2004 By Julian Sguera In
I guess this is primarily for people who listen to different kinds of music. How connected do you think the world of classical music is with mainstream music(I'm not talking about the social climate that leeches on to classical music, just the music itself as representative of the higher apsects of our lives). Which among "mainstream" musicians do you think represents similar ideals in their music? Do you believe in the potential of the rock movement in music to develop to the extent that "classical" did (which took hundreds of years)? Do you think modern musicians are already that good, and if so, why? Does the push to create hits and the commercial pressure to create huge sales numbers stand as a barrier to expanding the emotional reach of "mainstream" music? Or does the "classical" music being written today succesfully represent the qualities of the great musicians of the past? Just a sample of questions that could be discussed on this.
Comments
on Mar 02, 2004
May I be the first to formally welcome you to joeuser.com. I hope you enjoy blogging here and interacting with the community that is starting to develop here.

I wish you all the best

Sir Peter Maxwell
on Mar 03, 2004
Do you believe in the potential of the rock movement in music to develop to the extent that "classical" did (which took hundreds of years)?
I think that if you are asking if certain songs from the 20th century will be listened to in 200 years I would say yes. I think that some of the artists of today and yesterday were and are of such caliber, that they were above and beyond contemporary standards, that their music will demand to be heard.
Will it develop to the extent of classical, probably not, and that is somewhat for the better. We must remember that in the 17 and 1800, they had no recording devices to transmit music to a large audience. The people had to go to the performances and orchestras did not come cheap, so the artist either had to be very good, have a benefactor or well liked. And yes great musicians were discovered, it would be interesting to know how many were not liked because they did not fit in with the likes of the times. I know several famous ones “bucked” the system.
My example would be Goodman meeting Mick Jagger.
That is the benefit of today’s technology. Small bands can develop a following in the most remotest of places. One song from Frogswallow , Georgia, posted on a website can be heard in Berlin, Germany.


Do you think modern musicians are already that good, and if so, why?
I think that as Mozart and Bach et al. helped to define musical eras or the instruments they played. Hendrix, Billie Holiday, Goodman, Dylan do like wise to theirs.

Does the push to create hits and the commercial pressure to create huge sales numbers stand as a barrier to expanding the emotional reach of "mainstream" music?
Possible, but I am hopeful that the web and independent bands will help expand music.

IG
on Mar 10, 2004
Thanks Peter and Infogeek for your comments. Do you think the ease of creating and spreading music nowadays will lead to a situation where quantiy far exceeds quality? While I respect the brilliance of the above-mentioned musicians(especially Hendrix, who I feel had the rarest musical gifts), I think the discipline and knowledge required by older composers allowed them to display their ideas with far greater levels of sensitivity and expression than is possible nowadays. The amount of structure that supports a composition by someone loke Bach allows his ideas resonate with a depth and breadth that you just don't find in today's music. Just an opinion.
on Feb 03, 2005
FOUND YOU BRO - JASON
I tried 2 locate an email - but no luck at this end..
on Mar 21, 2005
Jules its Jason - Hey buddy - we gotta get in touch
on Jul 27, 2007
7/27/07

Jules - My email is:
scigone@gmail.com

email me - asap bro
it's been 2 long

Jason
www.myspace.com/scigone
on Jul 27, 2007